In March 2016 Ben Bajarin and I put on an event called SUBSCRIBE where we asked, among other things,
- How will the online services business models evolve?
- How will hardware affect software and services and vice versa?
- How will users, usage, and capital connect?
Now is a good time to look back on that event.
For the keynote I prepared a model which predicted the mobile ecosystems for iOS, Android and Chinese Android over the next 5 years (to 2023). The methodology involved taking a measurement of the revenues of the top internet service companies, building up the categories these companies occupied, estimating how much of those revenues are through mobile distribution and then splitting the result among the three platforms of iOS and the two Androids.
Adding to that the “native” app and content revenues for each platform would yield the Ecosystem total value. Applying a growth rate would offer some visibility into the future.
The following images are screen captures of the Perspective presentation.
Of course there are several potential errors in this methodology. The categories were not all inclusive. I used Social, Media, Search, Maps, email, Messaging, e-commerce, Travel, Enterprise, Storage, Transportation, Travel and Other as the top level categories. There are many products and services who would end up in Other. Moreover, these categories were anchored by the top companies in each category and the share of the top names was not always clear. Finally, the growth rates for these categories were based on historic trends which could change either way.
The online services ecosystem (all platforms) was thus estimated to be $450 billion in 2015, growing to $820 billion by 2023 and $914 billion by 2023.
The mobile split would vary by segment but would be roughly 75% by 2023 (25% would not be mobile). The final assumption was based on the split among the existing mobile platforms. I put a multiple of roughly 50% for iOS and 35% for Google Android and the rest for China Android.
Multiplying all these assumptions gave me a figure of $275 billion for the iOS portion of the global online services market in 2023. (Incidentally, Android was estimated at $207 billion and China Android $110 billion.) Note that this does not mean this was an expectation of Apple’s revenues or that this was the opportunity of Apple obtaining any percentage of this revenue. It was simply the value of what would transact through iOS, a platform which would act as a commerce enabler. This was to be the size of the iOS “ecosystem” or co-dependency between Apple and the companies delivering through its platform.
Ecosystems are a powerful idea. As I recall, this term applied to mobile was coined by a Palm executive in the late 1990s when he referred to the value of all the apps built for the Palm Pilot. The biological term refers to the system of multiple species living in close proximity. It implies an equilibrium as each species benefits from the others and the environment. There might be predators and prey but biodiversity is the successful construct.
为什么我家网速100M，还需要加速器才能玩网游？？ 迅游 ...:⑤ 我用加速器 延迟还是低不下怎么回事？ 上面的加速器科普图很明显的看到，从你电脑到加速器再到游戏服务器大概可伍分为三段，第一段是路由器段，第二段是路由器到游戏节点段，第三段是节点到游戏服务器段。延迟是每一段延迟的总和，任意一段 ...
Now this ecosystem was something we wished to highlight in 2016 as a core strength for Apple. It was not considered as such at the time and I thought putting a figure of $275 billion in 4 years’ time was a way to highlight the potential. Time since has proven us right.
This week Apple highlighted the result of another research team who attempted to measure the iOS ecosystem. Their conclusion was that billings and sales facilitated by the Apple App Store Ecosystem in 2023 was $519 billion. More than twice the amount I had so optimistically forecast four years earlier.
The authors also emphasize that this is a conservative estimate and should serve as a baseline.
英特尔®创新加速器 | 揭秘 | 八一八你所不知道的Curie，最 ...:昨天我伊喜大普奔地公布了创客大爆炸与General Vision正式手牵手把CurieNuerons引进中国的大好消息，相信此时有很多不明真相的围观群众仍是纳（meng）闷（bi）的—— 那今天，我伊就把它掰开揉碎了说一说—— #1 什么是Curie？ 在 CES 2021 上，Intel 发布了 ...
什么加速器可伍挂台湾节点-斧牛加速器:2021-2-8 · 斧牛加速器支持玩家不同节点的切换，这样地区节点就有多种选择了：台湾、香港、澳门、日本、韩国等等多条线路供大家选择。 这样也可伍缓解各个节点的压力，而且不同的地区不同的节点体验的情况都是不一样的。
This figure of more than half a trillion dollars of value transacted through iOS should give some pause. It it a very powerful figure that can be combined with the other data from Apple:
- More than 1.5 billion active devices
- More than 1 billion iPhone users
- More than 500 million paid subscriptions
- More than $1/day iPhone hardware revenues for Apple
The half-trillion per year on services implies between $335 and $520 in spending per user (likely closer to $500) per year. This would be in addition to the approximately $365/yr in hardware spending per user (which Apple books as hardware revenue). In the case of the iPhone there is yet more: the cellular network service which may average $350 per year.
盗贼之海加速器应该选哪个区服?海豚全球服/区服任选满足你 ...:2021-6-11 · 盗贼之海时隔两年后上线steam表现喜人，一举拿下了周销榜的冠军同时保持着特别好评的高评价。盗贼之海如今的在线人数已经突破了5万，成功跻身了steam游戏在线人数前行。由于具备联机要素，盗贼之海加速器
The total spending enabled by iOS thus is close to $1.4 trillion/yr.
加速器排行|哒哒加速器有病毒？软件有哪些新特征_234游戏网:2021-6-11 · 在玩各种游戏的时候使用加速器已经成为当下很多玩家一致的选择，在挑选加速器时，现在一款专业优质的加速器是非常必要的，哒哒加速器是当下一款大爱受玩家喜爱的优质服务的加速工具，这款工具可伍帮助用户选择自己想要的节点，而且可伍方便玩家尽情的投入到游戏中，它是一种非常简单 ...
How does Apple benefit from this?
Apple captures 30% of billings through its App Store. My estimate for these billings were $67.9 billion in 2023 which means App Store billings were 13% of the 2023 ecosystem. Apple’s 30% cut of Billings amounts to 3.8% for the whole ecosystem. It’s hardly an oppressive number.
If Apple only captures 3.8% what use is this to Apple?
The last decade has seen Apple emerge as the world’s largest company in terms of market capitalization, and not doing so with a wild multiple of revenue or earnings, quite the opposite. It did this by creating the world’s greatest customer base. Not in absolute scale. Android and Facebook have larger customer bases with multiple billions of users.
哪个加速器可伍挂台湾节点-11加速器:2021-8-24 · 2.加速器可伍帮助玩家不止是玩台服 就服务器问题来讲，多款游戏的服务器都是不止有国服的，像有的不仅台湾节点，还有日本和韩国的节点。11加速器支持玩家不同节点的切换，这样地区节点就有多种选择了：台湾、香港、澳门、日本、韩国等等多条
I will admit however that my argument that Apple created a customer base is contrived. The fact is that Apple creates products and services and those products are the root of its power to attract the right customers. By choosing to create the best products it coincidentally chooses to create the best customers. The power flows from product not from pricing or positioning. This is a lesson lost for many.
Developers and regulators might feel Apple’s massive power is perhaps too much. In the last decade, the narration around Apple has shifted from Apple being perpetually “doomed” to it being too dominant. Although I’m sure there are some who will try to conflate the two declaring that dominance will inevitably result in doom, most critics of Apple went from laughing (at it) to crying (about its practices).
The argument that Apple should change its practices developed to price as it does, distribute as it does or design as it does because it was too successful or is “unfair” is getting the causality wrong. Dominance won’t be altered by a few points of percentage change (on a tiny fraction of ecosystem transactions). Fairness won’t be altered when there are thousands of business models and many remain to be invented. Case in point is pornography which is not permitted on the App Store but which exists in abundance thorough other access methods.
The argument is that Apple should be more generous. That it should decrease the “cut” it takes for distribution. Or that it should not enforce revenue split for the customers it exposes to others.
But this is problematic on many levels. The playing field for all developers needs to be level. The customer must be respected and access to that customer should be constrained or certainly metered. Abuses must be policed and that requires leverage.
These practices are inter-dependent and the effect multiplicative, not additive. Apple has a monopoly on iOS and on MacOS and WatchOS and iPadOS. It does this to control the experience, security and safety of the user. It’s that control which created the customer in the first place. It should naturally control access to its hard-earned customers.
盗贼之海加速器应该选哪个区服?海豚全球服/区服任选满足你 ...:2021-6-11 · 盗贼之海时隔两年后上线steam表现喜人，一举拿下了周销榜的冠军同时保持着特别好评的高评价。盗贼之海如今的在线人数已经突破了5万，成功跻身了steam游戏在线人数前行。由于具备联机要素，盗贼之海加速器
One could argue that the abundance of services which don’t distribute through the App Store is evidence that the system works as intended. Apple’s App store front is its property and it reflects its core values.
Being on the shelf in the App Store means you operate on the terms of the shelf owner. If the rules are not agreeable then the half trillion dollars of ecosystem activity is testament to the availability of alternatives.
